Home / Outbound Benchmarks / Bounce per send vs per lead

Instantly's dashboard bounce rate vs bounce per lead: a 2.9% campaign was really 17.6%

Campaign analytics count sends; suspensions count leads. On a multi-step sequence the two differ by up to a factor of 6. Two measured cases and the method to recount.

Key finding: A campaign displayed at 2.9% bounce in Instantly's analytics (bounced_count over emails_sent_count) was at 17.6% per lead when recounted from the lead export: 3,803 leads, 30 inboxes all bouncing between 14% and 20%. A second workspace showed a campaign at 5.1% per send and 13.8% per lead, still active on an account that already had 5 suspended campaigns.
Measured onSeptember 4, 2026
SampleTwo workspaces: one campaign of 3,803 contacted leads (plus a sibling of 201), one workspace of 6 campaigns including 349 leads in the worst
MethodFull lead export of the campaign (paginated leads list), bounce = count of leads with bounced status divided by leads actually contacted (a last step recorded). Compared with the analytics endpoint's bounced_count / emails_sent_count on the same day. Per-inbox split using the sending account recorded on each lead's last step.
SourceVision Media internal measurement (campaign and API logs)
Dashboard figure vs per-lead figure
CampaignLeads contactedAnalytics (per send)Per lead (recount)Factor
Main campaign, 3.5-month engagement3,8032.9%17.6%6x
Sibling campaign, same 30 inboxes201n/a64.7%
Live entertainment campaign, other workspace3495.1%13.8% (48 leads)2.7x
Other campaigns in the second workspace, per lead, all still active
CampaignBounce per lead
Brokers7.1%
Betting8.8%
CPG8.1%
Crypto relaunch9.2%

Why the dashboard understates

A 3-step sequence sends up to three emails to a lead who did not bounce and exactly one to a lead who did. Dividing bounced leads by total sends therefore dilutes the bounce by the number of steps completed by the good leads. The platform's suspension logic, and the reputation damage on the sending domains, are driven by the per-lead figure.

What it hid

On the first case the 17.6% ran for the entire 3.5-month engagement, above the level at which another workspace had been suspended (19 to 22%). Open tracking was off (recommended for deliverability), so bounce per lead was the only placement signal available, and the dashboard figure hid it. The reply rate of 0.22% was blamed on targeting while a measurable part was deliverability. Per-inbox split: all 30 inboxes between 14 and 20% = uniform = the list, not the infrastructure.

How to recount

  1. Export every lead of the campaign (paginated list, filter by campaign).
  2. Bounce per lead = leads with bounced status (-1) divided by leads with a recorded last step.
  3. Group by the sending inbox on the last step: uniform rate across inboxes = list problem; concentrated on a few inboxes = infrastructure problem.
  4. Pause above 3% per lead. Do not include the provider code field: it is set on leads never contacted and inflates the count.

What this measurement does not say

Questions

What bounce rate gets an Instantly workspace suspended?

On our accounts, campaigns were suspended automatically at 19 to 22% bounce per lead, and one at 18% within 30 minutes of activation. The platform judges on the campaign's cumulative per-lead rate.

Related measurements

Want this run on your pipeline?

We operate multichannel outbound (cold email, LinkedIn, paid retargeting, newsletters) for B2B companies, and we measure it the way these pages do.

Book a call