How much of a 'verified' B2B contact list is actually catch-all or dead: GetLeads, Apollo, LeadMagic measured
Pools labeled VALID or verified by discovery databases, re-checked with a strict verifier and with real sends. 33 to 48% catch-all, and 6.7 to 23.3% bounce per lead when sent as is.
| Vertical | Bounce per lead |
|---|---|
| Media and TV | 23.3% |
| Live entertainment | 17.2% |
| Casinos | 16.1% |
| Sports teams | 13.8% |
| Gaming | 6.9% |
| Record labels | 6.7% |
| Verified campaigns, same 29 inboxes, same weeks | 1.2% to 4.5% |
| Source and label | Pool | Passed strict gate | Catch-all or dead |
|---|---|---|---|
| GetLeads email_status VALID (US marketing, hiring signal) | 1,133 | 714 (63%) | 419, of which 371 catch-all (33%) |
| GetLeads VALID, consumer brands, United Kingdom | 2,124 | 1,616 (76%) | about 20% catch-all |
| GetLeads VALID, consumer brands, United Arab Emirates | 542 | 306 (56.5%) | about 35% catch-all |
| Apollo 'verified', DTC brands 11 to 100 employees | 9,788 | 4,887 (50%) | 4,663 catch-all (48%) + 238 low score |
| LeadMagic 'valid' (energy drinks, reality TV) | 99 | 55 (56%) | 38 to 51% catch-all |
A score of 99 did not protect a reused pool
A campaign auto-activated on a pool reused from another project: 1,201 leads, every address scored 99 by the verifier. Result: 227 bounces, 18.9% per lead. All 227 carried the maximum score. The domains were financial and legal firms with accept-all servers: the verifier gives the maximum score to everything on such a domain. Gate on the status (deliverable and not catch-all), never on the score alone, and treat another project's data as an old dump even if it was 'verified' there.
What 'VALID' means at the source
Discovery databases infer the email from a pattern seen on the company domain and tag it VALID when the domain accepts the SMTP conversation. On catch-all domains that is a non-answer, and the share of catch-all domains depends on the vertical (media, entertainment, sports and gambling are far worse than marketing agencies) and on the country (the Gulf is dirtier than the United Kingdom). A 95% pass rate measured on one pool does not transfer to another.
Operating rule that came out of it
- Gate size and fit before deliverability: a verifier never fixes a wrong target.
- Remove recipient domains behind Mimecast or Sophos with a DNS lookup.
- Verify every address with a tool that decides catch-all; keep the status, not the score.
- On a pool from a new source, send 50 to 100 leads first and read the per-lead bounce at day 2 before releasing the volume.
- Pause any campaign above 3% bounce per lead; sending platforms suspend workspaces around 19 to 22%.
What this measurement does not say
- The six unverified verticals are consumer-facing industries known for high catch-all rates; B2B SaaS pools from the same source behave better.
- GetLeads migrated to a new dataset in October 2026; the catch-all shares above were measured on the previous dataset (July to August 2026).
- Apollo's 48% figure is a single large scrape of DTC brands with Google Workspace or Shopify-hosted mail, a population that is structurally accept-all.
Questions
Can I send to GetLeads VALID emails without verifying?
In our measurement, no: one third of VALID addresses were catch-all for a strict verifier, and unverified sends bounced at 6.7 to 23.3% per lead.
Why do Apollo verified emails bounce?
Because 'verified' does not say anything about catch-all: on 9,788 DTC addresses, 48% sat on accept-all domains. Those bounce at 20 to 30% when sent.
Related measurements
- Cold email bounce rate by recipient security gateway: Mimecast, Sophos, Proofpoint, Microsoft 365, Google
- Which email verifiers actually detect catch-all domains? The invented-address test
- Yahoo, Hotmail and AOL addresses flagged catch-all bounce at 18%; Gmail verifies cleanly
- Instantly's dashboard bounce rate vs bounce per lead: a 2.9% campaign was really 17.6%
Want this run on your pipeline?
We operate multichannel outbound (cold email, LinkedIn, paid retargeting, newsletters) for B2B companies, and we measure it the way these pages do.
Book a call