Which email verifiers actually detect catch-all domains? The invented-address test
A one-minute test any team can replicate: verify a made-up address on domains known to accept everything. A verifier that answers 'valid' is not probing catch-all. Results for BillionVerify, AgentsVerify and No2Bounce.
| Verifier | Domains tested | Answer on an address that cannot exist | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|---|
| BillionVerify | 9 | 'valid', smtp_deliverable, is_catchall=false on 9 of 9 | No random-recipient probe; a single 250 OK is enough |
| AgentsVerify | 10 | 'invalid' on 10 of 10 | Real catch-all probe |
| No2Bounce | 307 confirmed catch-all addresses | 'Deliverable/AcceptAll', catchall=true, score 99 on 307 of 307 | Flags the domain; does not decide the address |
Why this matters more than the vendor's accuracy claim
On B2B lists built from discovery databases, 26 to 48% of the addresses sit on catch-all domains in our pools (see the related measurement on discovery data). A verifier that calls every one of them 'valid' reports a 95% pass rate on a list that will bounce at 15 to 20%. The invented-address test exposes that in one API call per domain, before any credits are spent on the full list.
What 'catch-all' costs when you resubmit it
In September 2026 we re-submitted 307 addresses already marked catch-all by a first verifier to No2Bounce, hoping to rescue some of them. Result: 0 rescued out of 307; every one came back 'Deliverable/AcceptAll, catchall=true, score 99'. 307 credits for zero information. A confirmed catch-all is not an 'unknown': re-verifying it with a tool that does not probe only reconfirms what you already know.
How to run the test yourself
- Take 10 domains your current verifier marks as catch-all or accept-all.
- Submit an address like zq7x9random.nobody@domain with SMTP check and cache refresh forced.
- Count how many come back 'valid'. Anything above zero means the tool is not probing; its catch-all rate on your list is unknown.
What this measurement does not say
- Small domain counts (9 and 10). The result is binary and consistent, but a different set of domains could behave differently with greylisting or rate limits.
- Tested on one account per tool at one point in time; vendors change their probing logic.
Questions
What does catch-all mean for cold email?
The recipient's mail server accepts every address at the SMTP stage, so a verifier cannot tell whether the mailbox exists. In our B2B pools, catch-all addresses bounce at roughly 20 to 30% when sent without any further filtering.
Related measurements
- BillionVerify vs No2Bounce: tested against 455 real bounce outcomes
- AgentsVerify vs No2Bounce vs BillionVerify on the same 455 real bounce outcomes
- How much of a 'verified' B2B contact list is actually catch-all or dead: GetLeads, Apollo, LeadMagic measured
Want this run on your pipeline?
We operate multichannel outbound (cold email, LinkedIn, paid retargeting, newsletters) for B2B companies, and we measure it the way these pages do.
Book a call