AgentsVerify vs No2Bounce vs BillionVerify on the same 455 real bounce outcomes
The same 455-address ground-truth set, re-run through AgentsVerify in October 2026. It keeps 270 of 280 good addresses, really probes catch-all domains, costs 2.7x less than No2Bounce, and still misses bounces caused by security gateways.
| Tool | Good addresses kept (of 280) | Bounce rate of kept set | Invented address on 10 catch-all domains |
|---|---|---|---|
| No gate | 280 | 38.5% | n/a |
| AgentsVerify (Oct 2026) | 270 | 32.2% | 10 of 10 'invalid' |
| BillionVerify (Aug 2026) | 230 | 36.3% | 9 of 9 'valid' |
| No2Bounce strict: Deliverable and not catch-all (Jul 2026) | 140 | 43.3% | flags the domain as catch-all |
| Tool | Price | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| AgentsVerify | $0.00045 (100,000 credits for $44.70) | 500 free credits; 'unknown' and malformed addresses not charged; credits do not expire |
| No2Bounce | $0.0012 to $0.0017 | 100 free credits |
| BillionVerify | $0.0004 (20,000 per year for $96) | 600 free per month |
What AgentsVerify gets right
- It runs a real catch-all probe: an invented local part on 10 accept-all domains came back 'invalid' 10 times. BillionVerify had answered 'valid' 9 times out of 9 on the same kind of test.
- On addresses No2Bounce had labeled catch-all, AgentsVerify's 'valid' subset bounced at 22.5% versus 32.7% for the whole catch-all group: it separates some signal inside the zone No2Bounce cannot rank.
- Throughput: 465 addresses in about 3 minutes through the bulk endpoint.
What it still misses
128 of the 175 real bounces were labeled 'valid'. 78 of those sit on recipient domains whose MX points to a security gateway (Sophos and similar) that rejects mail based on the sender's reputation, after accepting the SMTP conversation. No SMTP-based verifier can observe that. On Google and Microsoft 365 recipients, its 'valid' addresses still bounced at 16 to 19% in this (deliberately difficult) set.
- 49 of 49 addresses on Sophos-gated domains bounced despite being 'valid'. The DNS-level MX filter remains mandatory before any send.
First production run
290 catch-all addresses from a fresh B2B pool (addresses that a first verifier had left undecided) were sent to AgentsVerify: 279 'valid' (96%), 9 'invalid', 2 'catch_all'. A 96% pass rate on catch-all addresses is high enough that we put those leads in separate campaigns to read their bounce rate on its own at day 2 before trusting it at scale.
Decision
After this test we moved all verification to AgentsVerify once remaining No2Bounce credits are used, with the MX gateway filter kept in front of it. The choice is driven by one thing: it decides catch-all addresses instead of discarding half of the good leads, at about 2.7 times lower cost.
What this measurement does not say
- The ground-truth set is biased: it was assembled because it bounced heavily, and the addresses were three months old by October. Absolute rates do not transfer to a normal list; only the comparison between tools does.
- The three tools were queried at different dates (July, August, October 2026) on the same addresses. Some addresses may have changed state in between, which can favor or penalize any of them.
- Production confirmation still pending: per-lead bounce at day 2 on the first AgentsVerify waves is the number that will validate or correct this page.
Questions
Which email verifier handles catch-all domains?
In our tests AgentsVerify was the only one of the three that correctly rejected invented addresses on accept-all domains (10 of 10). No2Bounce flags the domain as catch-all without deciding; BillionVerify accepts them.
Does a good verifier remove the need for an MX filter?
No. Bounces caused by security gateways (Mimecast, Sophos) are invisible to SMTP verification. We filter those recipient domains with a free DNS lookup before verifying anything.
Related measurements
- BillionVerify vs No2Bounce: tested against 455 real bounce outcomes
- Which email verifiers actually detect catch-all domains? The invented-address test
- Cold email bounce rate by recipient security gateway: Mimecast, Sophos, Proofpoint, Microsoft 365, Google
- How much of a 'verified' B2B contact list is actually catch-all or dead: GetLeads, Apollo, LeadMagic measured
Want this run on your pipeline?
We operate multichannel outbound (cold email, LinkedIn, paid retargeting, newsletters) for B2B companies, and we measure it the way these pages do.
Book a call