Low open rate? Cut by mailbox provider first: Gmail 5.7%, Google Workspace 40.9%, Office 365 93.3% on the same send
A B2C newsletter with a 6.1% open rate looked like broken tracking. Split by recipient provider, business mailboxes opened at 41 to 93% on the same pixel and the same domains. The problem was Gmail's Promotions tab, not the tracking.
| Recipient provider | Share of volume | Unique open rate |
|---|---|---|
| Gmail (consumer) | 97.4% | 5.72% |
| Google Workspace | small | 40.86% |
| Office 365 | small | 93.33% |
| All | 100% | 6.10% (2.20% excluding prefetched opens) |
Reading it
Business mailboxes are the control group: same pixel, same domains, same copy. If they open normally and consumer Gmail does not, the pixel is innocent and the issue is placement, in this case the Promotions tab. The format of the email (logo, hero image, call-to-action button, unsubscribe footer) is close to an automatic Promotions classification.
Which counter you quote
The platform exposes 'unique opens' and 'unique opens not prefetched'. The second is 2.8 times lower and comparable to nothing else on the market. Reporting the wrong one makes a healthy send look like a failure.
What this measurement does not say
- One send on one B2C list; the Workspace and Office 365 groups were small, so their rates carry wide error bars (Office 365 at 93% is a handful of recipients).
- Open rates on business mailboxes include prefetch and scanner opens as well.
Questions
How do I know if my open tracking is broken or if I am in Promotions?
Split opens by recipient provider. If Google Workspace and Office 365 recipients open normally and consumer Gmail does not, tracking works and placement is the problem.
Related measurements
Want this run on your pipeline?
We operate multichannel outbound (cold email, LinkedIn, paid retargeting, newsletters) for B2B companies, and we measure it the way these pages do.
Book a call