Cold email open and click rates are both inflated: 141 opens per 100 emails, 15% to 46% click rates from scanners
Apple Mail preloads tracking pixels; security gateways click every link. Measured on our own sends: 141 opens for 100 emails, a 15% click rate on day one, and 36 to 46% click rates uniform across unrelated lists, 40 clicks within 4 hours.
| Send | Metric | Value | Explanation |
|---|---|---|---|
| First wave, 100 emails | Unique opens per email | 141 per 100 | Apple Mail prefetches the pixel on every message, read or not |
| 271 delivered, day one | Click rate | 15.0% | Security gateways (Defender, Proofpoint, Barracuda...) follow every link to scan it |
| 8 subdomains, two regions, different lists and copy | Click rate | 36% to 46% on all of them | Identical rate everywhere and 40 clicks within 4 hours of sending |
| Same 271 delivered | Open rate | 28.1% | Mixed: humans plus prefetch |
What these rates still tell you
- An open or click rate near zero means the mail is landing in spam. Opens and clicks exist means it is not entirely in spam. That is a coarse placement test, nothing more.
- A reply is the only interest signal. A booked meeting is the only business KPI.
- Reliable placement needs seed accounts outside your own domains (personal Gmail, Outlook, Yahoo) and a look at which tab the mail lands in.
How to separate humans from scanners
- Time to click: a click less than two minutes after delivery is a scanner. Use the click webhook with timestamps, not the summary counts.
- Put a per-contact UTM on the call-to-action and count landings, not clicks.
- Count per recipient, never per event.
- One provider exposes both 'unique opens' and 'unique opens not prefetched'; the second is 2.8 times lower and is not comparable with any other tool's number. Know which counter you are quoting.
Reporting rule
We report the raw per-recipient rate because it is the number everyone compares, with the reserve above as a footnote. We never replace it with a 'corrected' figure, and we never present a two-digit click rate on cold email as prospect interest.
What this measurement does not say
- Mechanisms were identified from timing and uniformity, not from user-agent fingerprinting of each event.
- Share of Apple Mail recipients was not measured; the 141% figure is the observed maximum, not an average.
Questions
Why is my cold email click rate 40%?
Because security gateways click every link to scan it. In our data the rate was identical on unrelated lists and most clicks happened within 4 hours. Human click rates on cold email are 1 to 3%.
Is open rate useful for cold email?
Only near zero, as a spam indicator. Apple Mail prefetching produced 141 opens for 100 emails on one of our sends.
Related measurements
Want this run on your pipeline?
We operate multichannel outbound (cold email, LinkedIn, paid retargeting, newsletters) for B2B companies, and we measure it the way these pages do.
Book a call