LeadMagic 'unknown' is not a dead address: 54% pass a strict No2Bounce gate
1,332 academic and institutional emails verified by both LeadMagic email-validate and No2Bounce. More than half of LeadMagic's 'unknown' answers are deliverable; 15 of its 'valid' answers are dead.
| LeadMagic says | No2Bounce: Deliverable, not catch-all | No2Bounce: catch-all | No2Bounce: dead |
|---|---|---|---|
| valid | 299 | 138 | 15 |
| unknown | 228 | 153 | 45 |
| invalid | 9 | 1 | 30 |
| MX provider | Share of 'unknown' |
|---|---|
| Microsoft 365 | 58% |
| Proofpoint | 21% |
| Cisco IronPort | 10% |
| 0% |
Why institutional servers answer 'unknown'
Mail servers that accept every RCPT TO to prevent address enumeration (most Microsoft 365 tenants, Proofpoint and IronPort gateways) give the verifier nothing to decide on. Google answers precisely, so it never produces 'unknown'. On a university or hospital audience, 'unknown' can be a third of the list, and it contains the core of the audience (large universities and federal agencies were all 'unknown' here).
Practical rules
- Never gate on the verdict of the tool that found the address; cross it with a second verifier that reports catch-all.
- LeadMagic email-validate is free on 'unknown' answers and charges 0.25 credit per decided answer, about 20 checks per minute whatever the concurrency.
- What LeadMagic adds that the second verifier does not: the MX provider, needed for the Mimecast filter. The two tools are complementary, not redundant.
- Build the sending waves only after the MX data is complete: four Mimecast domains slipped into a campaign before this step was reordered.
What this measurement does not say
- Single audience type (academic and institutional). On SMB lists hosted on Google Workspace, 'unknown' is rare and this ratio does not apply.
- No2Bounce was the reference, not ground truth: its 'Deliverable, not catch-all' status has its own error rate (see the gateway and verifier benchmarks).
Questions
Should I delete LeadMagic 'unknown' emails?
No. In our test 54% of them were strictly deliverable according to a second verifier, and they included the most valuable institutional domains.
Related measurements
- AgentsVerify vs No2Bounce vs BillionVerify on the same 455 real bounce outcomes
- Cold email bounce rate by recipient security gateway: Mimecast, Sophos, Proofpoint, Microsoft 365, Google
- Which email verifiers actually detect catch-all domains? The invented-address test
Want this run on your pipeline?
We operate multichannel outbound (cold email, LinkedIn, paid retargeting, newsletters) for B2B companies, and we measure it the way these pages do.
Book a call